There was just too much talk about Verdant here to not at least give them a try, especially their green tea and pu’er, so when they had an excellent deal recently, I took them up.
This was one of the samples I requested. I have very limited experience with pu’er… just two others; one ‘beginner-friendly’ shu from a tea store that wasn’t too bad, and a sample of Guan Zi Zai 2005 from Life in Teacup.
I don’t have any concerns about sheng; to me, aged tea is no more strange than other aged things, cheese, wine, etc. So approaching this tea was no concern. In fact, I imagine shu is to tea as cabbage is to kim chee, sauerkraut, etc. and I love certain things that have been fermented well, so I can imagine enjoying shu a lot, as well. On the other hand, I have heard a lot of horror stories about it, so I would probably approach it more carefully.
I also enjoy (to a certain extent) earthy and smokey flavors, like mate (which is almost always smoked) or houjicha, so pu’er hasn’t seemed a strange concept to me, rather very intriguing.
I followed Verdant’s instructions, and using my makeshift gaiwan, put the remainder of my sample (3-4g) in, rinsed once, and used 2-3oz water per infusion, going up to about 17.
The leaf looked like it had actually been loose pu’er rather than pressed into a cake (the leaves were not stuck together and looked like dried, unrolled, dong fang mei ren [oriental beauty]), and as their description states, it sounds like the method of stone pressing causes the leaf to be loosely packed into the cake.
Since I have so little experience with sheng, I don’t know how that influences my impression of this tea. The first steepings (esp the first) had an underlying citrus-like sweetness. It wasn’t sweet like the returning sweetness in the back of the throat, but left an almost sweet flavor somewhere in the middle.
The aroma was a smokey-woody-earthiness, similar to mate but much smoother. I could say it was almost like what you would imagine an earthy cave to smell like (“not a nasty, dirty, wet hole, filled with the ends of worms and an oozy smell, nor yet a dry, bare, sandy hole”).
EDIT: I meant to add here – this was the best part about it for me and delicious!
Besides this smokey-woody flavor, which in one steeping reminded me of a nice savory/salty stew, it was a very smooth tea. I didn’t get much else from it, actually.
Late into the steepings, I experienced a very mouth-drying sensation that was almost unpleasant. I was hoping this would signal a shift in what the tea became/tasted like, but unfortunately it seemed to mean that the tea had only a couple pleasant (but not overly interesting) infusions left.
So, take my long review as you like, since while I know I am someone who could probably really enjoy pu’er, I don’t know a lot of what to expect (what makes one good or not). As far as whether I simply liked this tea- yes, I did, but it just wasn’t the same as Japanese greens.
I think I knew this before I started, but I don’t believe pu’er is something I will ever get into, at least not for this season of life. I don’t have hours to do long tea sessions and many infusions. The best I can get most days is one pot/4 infusions, but more often it is 3 infusions (for a Japanese tea, which is an easier brewing method than gaiwan, imo). I will certainly enjoy a few pots of pu’er here and there, but I simply don’t have the time to do it proper justice (via gaiwan).
Unless, someone who has a lot of experience with it can say that the western method works well? If I could do the western method and drink 3-4 infusions, instead of 15-20, that would be doable. Let me know if that really does good sheng/shu justice and what the parameters for each infusion could be (in general).
Try it without the teaball…
I probably should, and it would be even better to use a gaiwan, but brewing in one cup and pouring it into another tends to get a bit messy, and my mom yelled at me last time I did it…
When I get back to college this weekened, I’ll try it.
Investing in a finum brew basket will be worth it!
Thanks for the great idea! I’ll certainly look into it!
I loe following along with your steepings. So much fun! I alo second Bonnie’s brew basket suggestion- I think it’s my favorite “western” brewing implement.
Thanks for the positive feedback! Since you mentioned brew baskets as well, I will definitely be looking into getting one.
Better: http://amzn.com/B001713L84
Steep Western style, unconstrained in an open vessel, then decant through this device.
I rarely get on anyone’s case about equipment and technique, but tea baskets and tea balls significantly impact the quality in the cup.
Good suggestion, Jim!
When I use a brew basket, I use the large size, which fills up the whole volume of the cup I’m brewing in. As it is, I put the basket in a cup, the leaves float freely in the covered-cup-within-a-cup for the 2-5 seconds I’m steeping, and then I remove the basket and set it on it’s head/cover.
However, I agree that your suggestion this would be ideal if I had another smaller, glazed teapot (or cover-able vessel) OR if I were better at pouring without dripping everywhere (in which case, I would use a cup with it’s saucer on top). I will bookmark this, too, for when my gongfu strainer inevitably gets lost or broken.
I like Western Style also Jim, but for a smaller amount of
Pu-erh or quicker 20-30 sec. steepings in a mug, a Finum works well too.
I shouldn’t have said “Western” because that implies long steep times. I’ve just gotten so used to my gaiwan that I think of [non-yixing] tea pots as “Western”. Which I know is totally not true.
What I meant is steep in a vessel that is wide and open, regardless of how big or small, and then decant into a cup or mug. I have two beehive type pots that are, I think at most 8oz and may be only 6, that I use in this way when I want more than the 3.5oz I get from the gaiwan.
We have Finum like baskets and wide brew baskets (usually pulled out of cast iron kettles that some ninny thinks you’re supposed to brew tea in). Liz uses them a lot. Anecdotally, for myself, I find that they still constrain movement, and impact the cup.
I know what you mean…there’s no way I can do 5-6 steeps at 8oz each on a Pu anyway unless I dump most of each steep into a pitcher for having later cold (which I like).
So my 4oz clay Gaiwan or 6oz ceramic Gaiwan or PIAO 6oz is what I use when I review. BUT, when I’m just drinking a pot for myself and not reviewing…I sometimes go for 32oz and a big glass pot and steep longer and soak myself in puerh! (not literally but you know!) Pull out the bark and cover the pot with an old fashioned tea cozy and drink for a long while.
thanks for all the wonderful suggestions and tea wisdom. I’m personally leaning towards the brew basket (large size), since poouring from my cup to another seems to end with tea everywhere.
When I have more space/get an apartment, I’ll start looking tinto geting a more sophisticated setup (gaiwans, teapots, etc.) but for now it’s just not feasable.
Exactly Jim. Constrain movement….